Freedom Discussions

Time For Google To Leave Italy? Italy Announces That YouTube Responsible For All Content

Mili Note: Forget that this is about Google and focus on the implication here.  YouTube is a crowd-enabling platform.  This means that any of us can contribute to its content and Google has only limited control over it.  Yet according to the gunvernment of Italy, it’s a broadcaster and should be regulated (read: controlled) by said gunverment…

from TechDirt

Not this again. The Italian government has long had trouble comprehending how YouTube is simply a platform for users. Of course, some might say this is willful ignorance. Italy’s Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi owns Italy’s largest private broadcaster, Mediaset, and doesn’t much like the competition. In fact, back in 2008, Mediaset sued Google over its content appearing on YouTube, and a year ago, an Italian court (surprise, surprise) sided with Berlusconi and ordered YouTube to remove all Mediaset content, though it doesn’t explain how YouTube is to know what is and what is not infringing. Of course, this is also the same country where a politician wanted to sue thousands of YouTube commenters for making fun of him under a video on YouTube. And, most famously, Italy is the country that bizarrely and inconceivably found Google execs criminally liable for a video posted to Google Video.

The latest in the Italian government’s war against YouTube is that it’s declared that YouTubequalifies as a TV station and is subject to television regulations (Google translation of theoriginal Italian, found via Slashdot). What this means is that not only will YouTube/Google have to pay a tax as a TV broadcaster, but it now has other regulatory controls, including an obligation to publish “corrections” within 48 hours to anyone who claims they were slandered, and an obligation to not broadcast “inappropriate” content during times when children might watch.

But, of course, the biggest issue is that it says that if there’s any editiorial control, even automated (so I assume the “favorites” or “recommended” lists count), suddenly, YouTube becomes liable for all of the content. In other words, in order to help Berlusconi win his lawsuit against YouTube, Italian politicians have effectively changed the law to make sure that YouTube is now liable for the content of third party users. This effectively means that the risk of running such a platform in Italy becomes ridiculously high. I imagine Google will fight this in the courts, but at some point, it makes you wonder if Google wouldn’t just be better off leaving Italy altogether, and seeing how folks there feel about its government’s decisions.

Read the rest at this link.